Chipboard or plywood for subfloor

A long lasting solid hardwood floor is heavily influenced by the quality of the sub-floor. When it comes to types of sub-floors there is a wide range but we will focus on the two most often used in modern buildings.
Posted on02-01-2017 by 6674
Chipboard or plywood for subfloor

Chipboard or plywood? Which is better?

A long lasting solid hardwood floor is heavily influenced by the quality of the sub-floor. When it comes to types of sub-floors there is a wide range but we will focus on the two most often used in modern buildings.

First lets understand how each one is manufactured:

Structural Plywood - it is made of three or more thin layers of wood bonded together with adhesive and compressed under high pressure. Each layer is oriented with its grain running perpendicular to the adjacent layer. This provides dimensional stability and improves the strength of the board. The standard dimensions are 1220mm x 2440mm or 4 ft by 8 ft. It comes in various thickness but for our comparison we will consider 18mm thick plywood.

Treated Chipboard - it is made by bonding together wood particles (chips) with an adhesive under heat and pressure to form a rigid board with a relatively smooth surface. For sub-floors we will consider 18mm thickness tongue and groove with dimensions of 600mm x 2400mm.

Installation

Chipboard is faster to install as it has tongue and groove. The boards are laid lengthwise, perpendicular, over joists and joined together. Screws are needed to fix down the new sub-floor. Since it has tongue and groove the joints which end between the joists do not need extra reinforcement thus less work. The off cut resulted at the end of the row will be used to start the new row. Also the narrower board maneuvers more easily especially in tighter places

Plywood is slower to install due to its larger dimensions. Since it has no tongue and groove it has to be cut so the joints will fall in the middle of the joists and when this is not possible additional noggins will have to be fitted under the joint.

Sub-floor strength and long term dimensional stability

Both materials provide a good strength yet the plywood being made out of continuous layers of wood is a lot sturdier when heavy items are dropped. Most of time if the impact fall between the joists over the clear chipboard this will break it.
On the long term the chipboard tends to sag due to moisture variations as well as heavy objects pressing down or even constant traffic. Once again, the plywood, due to its construction will retain its original characteristics.

Moisture resistance

For sub-floors both materials should be treated from the manufacturing process.  The chipboard will last for a shorter time than plywood in similar conditions as in the end the small chips will expand by absorbing moisture and will crumble. Instead plywood will withstand for a much longer time. Eventually the layers will separate and the board will loose the strength but will not crumble.

Noise

If installed correctly plywood will not make a noise. On the other hand chipboard is renowned for squeakiness which gets worse and worse as time passes and the floor endures more traffic. This happens even if the chipboard is glued between the joints and it is due to its sagging tendency.

Price

Up to now there is no doubt that plywood should be used to create a solid long lasting sub-floor. This comes as usually with the price disadvantage since the plywood on a square meter is often double in price than chipboard.

Our recommendation

When our projects involve reworking the timber sub-floor we will use plywood as this will preserve the quality of new wooden floor which we'll have to install over.

Sub-floors are the key aspect in delivering a successful outcome and should be assessed and treated consciously. We are prepared to take your technical questions.

Related articles
Pine end grain block wooden floor brings a scandinavian look to Tower Bridge, E1

Pine end grain block wooden floor brings a scandinavian look to Tower Bridge, E1

154 15-08-2019
Our reputation, expertise and skills in making and fitting end grain flooring were recognised by our clients,...
Which adhesive is recommended for gluing down a hardwood floor?

Which adhesive is recommended for gluing down a hardwood floor?

197 07-08-2019
Wood flooring has been used for thousands of years. However, glued down floors or stuck down wooden floors are a...
Why You should Install Proper Soundproofing in Flats with Wooden Flooring

Why You should Install Proper Soundproofing in Flats with Wooden Flooring

280 18-07-2019
If you’ve ever thought about installing wood flooring in a flat or apartment, without adequate sound proofing, it’s...
Stair cladding & Wood flooring makes a lasting impression in Wimbledon

Stair cladding & Wood flooring makes a lasting impression in Wimbledon

728 10-02-2019
For our latest project we removed a damaged jatoba wooden floor from a house in Wimbledon, replacing it with a...
Curved Parquet Gives Kitchen Floor The Edge

Curved Parquet Gives Kitchen Floor The Edge

869 25-01-2019
Fitting a new parquet wooden floor is rewarding because it can completely transform the look and feel of a room.This...
Herringbone Parquet Replaces New Carpet and Transforms Home

Herringbone Parquet Replaces New Carpet and Transforms Home

802 11-10-2018
You can never have too much of a good thing. That’s what the homeowners of a converted Victorian property thought...
Floor Levelling Explained:  An Expert Guide

Floor Levelling Explained: An Expert Guide

538 20-09-2018
Wonky, uneven and sloping floors are a common feature in older properties and so we often get asked how to level an...
1970’s House Updated with Improved Subfloor & New Parquet Floor

1970’s House Updated with Improved Subfloor & New Parquet Floor

1064 06-07-2018
In the case of wood flooring, preparation is key. If your subfloor isn’t strong and level, then a new wooden floor...
Underfloor Heating & Wood Flooring: An Expert Guide

Underfloor Heating & Wood Flooring: An Expert Guide

1082 03-07-2018
Underfloor heating (UFH) is as popular as ever and we are very experienced at fitting wood flooring with it. Wood is...
Bespoke Wood Floor & Headboard Create Stunning A Home

Bespoke Wood Floor & Headboard Create Stunning A Home

706 31-05-2018
We knew exactly what to suggest for this brief, a bespoke end grain block wooden floor. This spectacular floor isn’t...
Wood flooring and Soundproofing: an Expert Advice

Wood flooring and Soundproofing: an Expert Advice

2253 23-05-2018
Planning to install a new wooden floor, but live in an older style flat? If you do, you will definitely need some...
A complete soundproofing solution for a London flat

A complete soundproofing solution for a London flat

1060 25-03-2018
If you live in a flat and want a wooden floor, the chances are you’ll need to install some sort of soundproofing. For...
Leave a Comment
Leave a Reply
Please login to post a comment.

Menu

QR code

Settings

Settings

Create a free account to save liked items.

Sign in

Create a free account to use wishlists.

Sign in